Democrat Bryan Tanner elected St. Joseph County Council president with Republican support

ST. JOSEPH COUNTY, Ind. -- The St. Joseph County Council will move forward under new leadership after members elected Democrat Bryan Tanner as Council President Tuesday night, despite Republicans holding the majority.

Tanner, formerly President Pro-Tem, won the position on a 6-3 vote, securing support from two of the council’s five Republicans.

The vote follows continued tension among Republicans after former council president Daniel Schaetzle faced criticism from fellow GOP members for what they described as an overly bipartisan approach while leading the council.

Schaetzle defended his record, pointing to conservative policy decisions during his tenure.

“I have voted for economic development. I voted for a new abatement ordinance that's easier for businesses to use,” Schaetzle said. “I think my record is very conservative.”

Ahead of Tuesday’s election, Schaetzle said he attempted to mend relationships within his party, sending a message to Councilman Randy Figg on Dec. 31, offering to nominate him for vice president pro tem. Figg said the offer came with a deadline and was not well received.

“He's a Republican not in good standing,” Figg said. “I got to be careful…I'm a Republican in good standing and represent my people.”

Despite losing the presidency position, Schaetzle said he is optimistic about his new role as President Pro-Tem.

“The presidency is a high stress position, and I loved doing it. I love serving the people of St. Joseph County, but I think this is answer to prayer, I needed a little less stress in my life,” Schaetzle said. “We have a history of working well together in a bipartisan fashion and I think that will continue.”

Figg echoed that sentiment, voting in favor of Tanner’s nomination and emphasizing a policy-focused approach.

“I thought it was time for a change,” Figg said. “I got to look at the policy. So I'll work with anybody.”

Tanner stated he was too busy for comment following the vote. Republicans serving alongside him said they are eager to work together as regular County Council meetings resume next week.